Welcome to Abe's Pizza Monticello
Abe's Pizza Monticello, located at 234 N Main St, is a delightful pizza haven in Monticello, IN. Renowned for its made-to-order pizzas, this cozy eatery offers a variety of crusts—from thin and crunchy to deep-dish options. Customers rave about the flavorful toppings, particularly the Italian sausage, and the delicious garlic butter breadsticks. The inviting atmosphere and friendly service enhance the dining experience, making it ideal for families and casual diners alike. With positive reviews highlighting both the quality of food and the affable staff, Abe's Pizza Monticello is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers in the area.
Abe's Pizza Monticello: Reviews & Ratings
My sister and I decided to stop for lunch. Ordered a 14 in cheese pizza, thin crust. It was absolutely delicious! The crust was nice and crunchy, but not burnt. Priced right. I believe Shirley was our waitress. Such a sweetheart. Abe's was also very well kept. I'll definitely stop in again when I'm in the area.
Awesome pizza am glad you guys deliver if I ever come back to this town to get another load am calling you guys.
Stopped in town for the night. Kids wanted pizza. Grabbed a large za and some bread sticks. Lemme tell yah; the diner is so cute, the service was perfect, and the food was delicious! Thanks for dinner yall :)
It was our first time ordering from here and omgosh so good way better then Pizza Hut we are definitely ordering again from here soon !!
Cozy setting. Pizza is made to order. Thin, hand rolled, deep dish. We liked the Italian sausage the best. We tried both hand rolled and thin, both were good. Next week we will try the deep dish. Oh yeah the bread sticks with garlic butter, they were great. ...
We live in Rensselaer and go to Monticello a couple times a year. We always go to Abe's and it is consistently GOOD! This year we have made many trips and absolutely think this is the best pizza around. Sweet "Shirley" our waitress is one of a kind and you just gotta love her. This place is the best and will return many more times in the future... Try it and you will be back......Promise:-)
Nice people running the place. Good pizza. A great home town pizza joint.
A fantastic local pizza place! I highly recommend their bread sticks and nacho cheese, along with the meat pizza. (Be ready for a LOT of meat - it's loaded!)
Location
-
234 N Main St, Monticello, IN 47960, United States Hotline: +1 574-583-9600
Welcome to Abe's Pizza Monticello, a charming gem nestled in the heart of Monticello, Indiana. Located at 234 N Main St, this delightful pizzeria is a haven for pizza lovers craving quality and flavor. With a phone call to +1 574-583-9600, you can experience the joy of freshly made, mouthwatering pizzas delivered right to your door.
As you step inside, you're greeted by a cozy setting that feels like home. The ambiance is warm and inviting, making it an ideal spot for families and friends to gather. Customers frequently rave about the diner’s cleanliness and overall charm, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience.
The star of the show, of course, is the pizza. With options like thin-crust and deep-dish, made from scratch and baked to perfection, every bite is a celebration of flavors. A customer noted how delicious and crunchy the thin crust is—without being burnt—perfectly paired with gooey cheese. Another devotee swears by the Italian sausage topping, declaring it one of the best they've tried. The variety of crusts ensures that every preference is met, making it a versatile choice for pizza enthusiasts.
Abe's doesn't stop at just pizza. Their breadsticks, accompanied by rich garlic butter, are also highly praised, serving as the perfect complement to any meal. These little bites of goodness have been enough to win over even the most discerning palates.
Exceptional service is another hallmark of Abe's Pizza Monticello. Staff members, like Shirley, are remembered fondly for their friendliness and attentiveness, creating a welcoming atmosphere for newcomers and locals alike. Customers often express gratitude for not just the food, but the experience—where they leave with a full stomach and a smile.
Whether you're a local or just passing through, Abe’s Pizza Monticello promises a culinary adventure that resonates with hearty flavors and exceptional service. Trust me, one visit is all it takes to understand why customers eagerly return to this beloved pizzeria. So why wait? Stop by or call to indulge in a dining experience that embodies the spirit of Monticello.